Duplicate payments are a common occurrence in accounts payable (AP) departments. It happens when an invoice is accidentally paid twice, resulting in the vendor receiving more money than they are owed. This can lead to financial losses for the company and can also damage vendor relationships.

In fact, according to the Institute of Finance and Management (IOFM), organizations lose an average of 0.1% to 0.05% of their total spend on duplicate payments. This seemingly small percentage can add up to significant financial losses, especially for large companies with substantial accounts payable volumes. 

In this blog, we will discuss how duplicate payments happen and provide 10 ways to prevent them from occurring in your AP department.

What are Duplicate Payments in Accounts Payable?

Simply put, duplicate payments are when the same invoice is paid more than once by a business. This can happen due to various reasons such as human error, system glitches, or AP fraud.

For example, let’s say you receive an invoice for $1000 from your vendor and make the payment. However, due to a clerical error, the same invoice is processed again and another payment of $1000 is made. This results in an overpayment of $1000 and creates a duplicate payment situation.

Impact of Duplicate Payments on Businesses

Just like we talked about above, duplicate payments can result in overpayments and cause financial losses for businesses. Every duplicate payment represents a financial loss. When businesses pay the same invoice twice, it directly impacts cash flow and reduces available funds for other expenses.

Additionally, the time spent identifying and rectifying duplicate payments is time that could be better spent on more productive tasks. When duplicate payments occur, AP teams often spend time resolving these issues instead of focusing on taking advantage of early payment discounts or avoiding late fees. This distraction can lead to missed opportunities for cost savings and additional penalties.

Moreover, duplicate payments can also strain relationships with vendors as they may become frustrated with the delay in resolving the issue and receiving their rightful payment. This can lead to strained business relationships and potentially harm future partnerships.

Common Reasons Duplicate Payments Happen

While duplicate payments can happen for a variety of reasons, here are a few ways they commonly occur:

• Data Entry Mistakes: One common cause of duplicate payments is simply human error. Incorrectly entered data, whether it’s a vendor name, invoice number, or payment amount, can result in the same invoice being processed and paid more than once. This highlights the importance of careful and thorough data entry processes to prevent these types of errors.
• No Automated Systems: Manual processing and approval systems are much more prone to errors and oversights than automated systems. By implementing automation wherever possible in the AP process, companies can greatly reduce the risk of duplicate payments. This includes utilizing software like Sage Intacct for invoice scanning and data capture, as well as electronic approval workflows.
• Payments Made Outside of AP Departments: When payments are made outside of the designated AP departments, it increases the risk of duplicate payments. This could look like a manager or employee making payment directly to a vendor, bypassing the proper channels and controls. Obviously, this lack of centralized control can lead to confusion and repeated payments.
• No Centralized Process: Without a centralized process for receiving and managing invoices, it’s easy for duplicate invoices to slip through the cracks and be paid multiple times. This can look like invoices being sent to multiple departments or individuals within a company, with no clear oversight or communication between them.
• No Digital Payments: Relying on manual processes and paper invoices increases the likelihood of duplicate payments. Digital payments and electronic fund transfers (EFT) provide more control and reduce the chances of human error.
• Payment Scams: Fraudsters often exploit weaknesses in the AP process to commit fraud, leading to duplicate payments. Without strong internal controls, businesses are vulnerable to these scams. This can look like fake invoices or altered payment details being submitted and approved for payment.
• Duplicate File Entries: Duplicate vendor entries and inaccurate data in your ERP system can lead to duplicate payments. Ensuring that your vendor master file is up-to-date and accurate is crucial.

How Do I Fix Duplicate Payments?

If a duplicate payment occurs, addressing it promptly is crucial to maintaining accurate financial records and good vendor relationships. Here are the steps to effectively fix duplicate payments:

Identify the Duplicate Payment

First, you need to identify the duplicate payment. Conduct a thorough review of your accounts payable records to confirm the duplicate payment, checking invoice numbers, payment amounts, and vendor details. Leveraging AP automation tools like Sage Intacct can help quickly identify and flag potential duplicate payments by comparing current payments against historical data.

Check out our blog on the top 15 benefits of AP automation.

Notify the Vendor

Once you have identified the duplicate payment, notify the vendor promptly. Clear communication is essential to resolve the issue quickly and maintain a good relationship with the vendor. Discuss resolution options with the vendor, such as requesting a refund, applying the extra payment to a future invoice, or adjusting future transactions.

Adjust Your Records 

Next, adjust your accounting records to reflect the correction. Document the duplicate payment in your accounting system, including details of the original payment, the duplicate payment, and any communications with the vendor. Reconcile your accounts payable and general ledger to ensure your financial statements accurately represent the resolved duplicate payment.

Conduct a Review

Implementing corrective actions is crucial to prevent future occurrences. Conduct an internal review to investigate how the duplicate payment happened, identifying any weaknesses in your AP process. This might involve reviewing manual data entry procedures, approval workflows, or system controls. Strengthen your internal controls by automating invoice processing, standardizing data entry procedures, and improving communication within the AP team.

Establish an Audit Process

Finally, establish regular monitoring and auditing practices. Schedule regular audits of your accounts payable processes to identify and correct any discrepancies, ensuring that your controls are effective and that duplicate payments are promptly detected and addressed. Continuous monitoring systems can also help by providing real-time alerts for potential duplicate payments, allowing for immediate action.

By following these steps, you can effectively fix duplicate payments and prevent them from recurring. 

10 Ways to Prevent Duplicate Payments

Preventing duplicate payments in accounts payable (AP) requires a combination of automation, standardized processes, and vigilant oversight. Here are some key strategies to avoid these costly errors:

1. Implement Accurate Data Entry Practices

Human error is a common cause of duplicate payments. Incorrectly entered data, such as vendor names, invoice numbers, or payment amounts, can result in the same invoice being processed and paid more than once. To reduce these errors, use AP automation software like Sage Intacct to capture and input data from invoices automatically. Establish clear, consistent data entry protocols and provide regular training for your AP teams to minimize errors, ensuring everyone follows the same steps.

2. Leverage Automated Systems

Manual processing and approval systems are prone to errors and oversights. Implementing automation can greatly reduce the risk of duplicate payments. Software that automatically captures and processes invoice data ensures accuracy and efficiency. Automated approval workflows ensure that invoices are reviewed and approved consistently, reducing the chance of invoices being processed multiple times.

3. Centralize Payments Within AP Departments

Payments made outside of the designated AP departments increase the risk of duplicates. Centralize payment processes to ensure all payments are processed through the AP department, maintaining oversight and consistency. Limit the ability to make payments to authorized AP personnel only, reducing the risk of unauthorized payments.

4. Establish a Centralized Process for Receiving Invoices

A centralized process for receiving and managing invoices prevents duplicate invoices from being paid multiple times. Direct all invoices to a single point of entry, whether it’s a physical address, an email inbox, or a digital portal. Implement a system that tracks all invoices from receipt to payment, ensuring clear communication and oversight to prevent invoices from slipping through the cracks.

5. Transition to Digital Payments

Relying on manual processes and paper invoices increases the likelihood of duplicate payments. Digital payments and electronic fund transfers (EFT) provide more control and reduce human error. Adopt digital payment methods like EFTs to improve control and tracking. Encourage vendors to submit invoices electronically, as digital invoices are easier to track and manage than paper ones.

6. Strengthen Internal Controls Against Payment Scams

Fraudsters can exploit weaknesses in the AP process, leading to duplicate payments. Protect your business by establishing robust verification processes to detect and prevent fraudulent invoices. Regular audits and continuous monitoring of AP activities can help identify and address any suspicious transactions, catching and preventing payment scams.

7. Maintain an Accurate Vendor Master File

Duplicate vendor entries and inaccurate data in your ERP system can lead to duplicate payments. Periodically audit and update your vendor master file to remove duplicate entries and correct inaccuracies. Use AP automation tools to maintain accurate and consistent vendor information, ensuring your vendor records are up-to-date and error-free.

8. Check for Double Invoicing

Double invoicing occurs when the same invoice is submitted and processed multiple times. Implement systems that automatically check for duplicate invoice numbers, amounts, and vendor details. Regularly review invoices to catch any potential duplicates before payments are made.

9. Look for Duplicate Vendors

Duplicate vendor entries can lead to multiple payments for the same invoice. Regularly audit your vendor list to identify and merge duplicate vendor entries. Use AP automation tools to automatically flag potential duplicates in your vendor master file.

10. Get W-4 Data from Each Vendor

Collecting W-4 data from each vendor ensures that your vendor records are complete and accurate. This helps in verifying vendor identities and reducing the risk of fraudulent invoices. Make it a standard practice to gather W-4 forms as part of your vendor onboarding process.

By integrating these strategies and leveraging AP automation software like Sage Intacct, businesses can create a more efficient, reliable, and error-free accounts payable process. This comprehensive approach ensures that duplicate payments are minimized, leading to better financial management and stronger vendor relationships.

Wrapping Up: Prevent Duplicate Payments

With the increasing volume of invoices and payment details that businesses handle on a daily basis, the risk of duplicate payments can be significant. As we’ve learned, duplicate payments occur when an invoice or payment is processed more than once, resulting in money being paid out twice for the same transaction. Not only does this lead to financial losses for the company, but it also causes major problems for both AP teams and vendors alike.

To combat this issue, many businesses are turning to automated solutions like Sage Intacct. This cloud-based financial management system offers a range of features to help prevent duplicate payments and make your AP processes easier.

For more information on how Sage Intacct and BCS ProSoft can help you prevent duplicate payments, contact us today. Our team of experts is ready to assist you in optimizing your accounts payable processes and achieving greater financial accuracy and control.

Frequently Asked Questions